Golf Travel Golf Courses Golf Real Estate the best of golf
Home > Best of Golf > Head to Head golf matchups > Pebble Beach vs. Pacific Dunes
Pebble Beach vs. Pacific Dunes Golf Course
© L.C. Lambrecht

As innocent and well-meaning as they are, the “Bandonistas” are also relentless, emphatic and so sure of themselves

They had really started to annoy me. As innocent and well-meaning as they were, they were also relentless—and so emphatic, so damned sure of themselves. For the better part of three years I had suffered their gushing pronouncements and smug sermons, nodding patiently and feigning enthrallment with a series of politely timed “Wow!”s, “Really?”s and “No kidding!”s. By last spring, however, I had heard enough.

I’m referring, of course, to golf’s fastest-growing cult: the Bandonistas, that fraternity of fanatics conjoined and consumed by the conviction that true golf Nirvana can be achieved only on a dreary stretch of coastline in southern Oregon.

Ever since the official opening of the Bandon Dunes golf course in 1999—an opening I was unfortunately unable to attend—the reports had been streaming back.

“You have to see this place,” said one of my colleagues. “It’s unlike anything in the U.S.”

“Pure golf at its finest,” said another.

“More Scottish than Scotland,” said a third, in a particularly irksome tone. I was intrigued, but also busy, so all I could do was sit and listen as the breathless raves continued, not just from golf insiders but regular hacks as well—friends of mine who took delight in regaling me on the charm and challenge of a course they had seen but I hadn’t. Then, in 2001, just when I thought the torrent of platitudes might end, it spewed forth again, worse than ever, with the opening of a second course on the same spot—Pacific Dunes.

“I didn’t think Bandon could be topped, but this one did it.”

“It’s brutal but bewitching—Ballybunion with better views.”

“I needed three days just to lift my lower jaw and restore my eyes back to their sockets.”

“I’ve just booked the 18th tee for my wedding—and my funeral.”

At the end of that year, when Golf magazine’s biennial course rankings appeared, there was Bandon Dunes as 70th in the world and Pacific Dunes, in its debut, an astonishing 26th. Word had spread among the cognoscenti that, once this layout matured a bit—and more people got to see it—Pacific Dunes might actually become regarded as the No. 1 course on the planet.  




Related Links:

Pebble Beach

Pacific Dunes


continued on page 2...
page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6
Bay Hill vs Doral Golf Courses Florida Golf Head to Head:
Bay Hill vs. Doral
Which is the better test?
read more »
Bernard Darwin Golf Writer Herbert Warren Wind Golf Five Lessons: the Modern Fundamentals of Golf Ben Hogan Head to Head:
Bernard Darwin vs. Herbert Warren Wind
Who was the better writer?
read more »
Shoreacres vs. Fishers Island Private Golf Clubs Head to Head:
Shoreacres vs. Fishers Island
Which is the better golf experience?
read more »
Augusta National Golf Course Pine Valley Golf Course Head to Head:
Augusta National vs. Pine Valley
Which is more prestigious?
read more »
Ping Eye2 vs. Callaway Big Bertha Golf Club Iron Driver Head to Head:
Ping Eye2 vs. Callaway Big Bertha
Which had a bigger impact on golf equipment?
read more »
Greenbrier vs. Homestead Golf Travel Vacation Resorts Resort Profile:
The Greenbrier vs. The Homestead

read more »

A.W. Tillinghast vs. Donald Ross
Who was the better architect?
read more »

Arnold Palmer vs. Phil Mickelson
Who is the better No. 2?
read more »

Pebble Beach vs. Pacific Dunes
As innocent and well-meaning as they are, the “Bandonistas” are also relentless, emphatic and so sure of themselves
read more »



Ernie Els LINKS Magazine Columns

subscription center

subscribe now
Sign Up for our Free LINKS Insider E-Newsletter
advertisement
e-brochures
view all
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
Skywater over Horseshoe Bay
 
home | site map | subscribe to LINKS Magazine | subscription changes | feedback | contact us | advertising information | order back issues | get FREE information | links e-newsletter registration | links partners | privacy policy | terms and conditions