Clicky

Norman in Mexico: A Double Appreciation

By: James A. Frank

An old expression says that travel is broadening. A recent trip to Mexico certainly opened my eyes.

First, I was introduced to a company called Vidanta, which has developed seven luxury-resort/time-share properties around the country. I stayed at Vidanta Nuevo Vallarta, one of their developments near Puerto Vallarta, which offers a range of accommodations, dining, activities, and everything else anyone could possibly want in a spectacular oceanside setting. Having experienced one, I want to enjoy some of Vidanta’s other properties, which can be found in Los Cabos, Acapulco, Mazatlan, and other Mexican destinations. And most of them have golf.

Which brings me to the second revelation: Greg Norman is a better golf course architect than many people realize.

Mexi

The principal reason for the Nuevo Vallarta visit was the unveiling of Vidanta’s new Norman Signature Course, which features very wide fairways, small bunkers, long waste areas, and fast greens with plenty of subtle breaks and surrounded by tricky collection areas. The course was great fun with the challenge increasing exponentially as the tees moved back: The longer tees offered better, more interesting angles into the spacious fairways but also demanded more forced carries and dealing with the ocean breezes that make tropical golf tricky, particularly in the afternoons.

According to Norman—who was on hand for the official opening and sat down with the media to chat—Nuevo Vallarta is his 101st completed course, there are another 20 or so in some stage of development, and he expects to soon start a bunch more. Most of his finished work is overseas and he’s presently very busy in South America, Asia, and Australia (plus looking for sites in Cuba). But he was confident that prospects would be picking up for him and others in the U.S. 

I asked if it bothered him to not get more credit as a designer. Norman is always honest and thoughtful, and he was very diplomatic in answering. And while I didn’t hit a nerve exactly he’s obviously been asked that question before and it vexes him. He said that the volume of work alone would indicate that he’s well regarded, and he made the point that his firm only takes on quality projects and does not (yet) do redesign work other than touching up his own older courses. And while he has associates working on-site, Greg makes numerous visits to each job, sometimes dozens of them, offering more than just a little tweak here and there. The man is involved.

Norman

All of which got me thinking about other Norman designs I’ve seen or played. While only a few, certain traits are consistent, starting with those wide fairways and challenging green sites, and including an appreciation for the scenery on and around the course. When asked how he first appraises a piece of land, Norman said he looks closely for natural elements to incorporate—water, elevation changes, and especially specimen trees—then looks up at what’s in the longer view. At Nuevo Vallarta, for example, the Sierra Madre Mountains are visible for nearly 360 degrees around and he wants golfers to see and enjoy them.

I won’t go so far as to call Greg a “minimalist”: There are too many pushed-up greens (whether for design effect or water flow) and the collection areas can be severe (short is usually better than long, while trying to save part from the sides can be particularly tough). But other than some strangely placed tee boxes, which were partly the result of water issues, this course felt very natural. And the more I thought, so did the other Norman courses I’ve played. They can be hard, but they never feel contrived.

Norman2

As for hard, Nuevo Vallarta will be much more so in a few months when five new holes replace five already there. The change is being made for a few reasons, including flooding issues with the nearby Ameca River and some ambitious plans Vidanta has for the property, notably a Cirque du Soleil entertainment park that is scheduled to open in 2018. The new holes—which should be in play by mid-February—include an island-green par three, carries over the river, and slightly tighter fairways. Plus, while we were driving the yet-to-grow-in holes, we spotted an alligator that the superintendent said was the biggest he’s seen on site, about four meters long.

There’s more golf at Nuevo Vallarta, as well. A very cool par-three course is presently being built among the high-rise accommodations; it will open this winter and will be lit for night-time play. The original course is a Jack Nicklaus design that will need to be changed to accommodate the Cirque du Soleil park. When it's done, which should be by Spring 2018, the Nicklaus and Norman courses will offer a unique opportunity to see the two architects’ work side by side. Of course, it’s silly to judge them solely on just these two courses, particularly since Jack has three or four times as many designs around the world in a much longer career. Yet I’ll bet that Greg’s work will prove a welcome surprise to many as it was to me. And also like me, it will make them want to search out and play more of them.

_______________

Have you played golf in Mexico? If so, where did you play and what did you think of it? Tell us in the comments below!

---

Feedback

  1. I have played a few courses in Mexico but my favorite is another one of Norman’s design; El Cameleon @ Mayakoba. WOW!!

    — Bob Forberg · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  2. Albeit in a limited sample, I did not like 100% of the Greg Norman courses I played, to the point of not wanting to play them or any other Norman course again.

    — Butch · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  3. By far, my favorite course in Mexico is the Dunes Course at Diamante in Cabo San Lucas. An absolute gem! Quivira is the most picturesque, but after a 6 hour round because the rangers have no power, I won’t go back.

    El Cameleon is my favorite Cancun course. Norman really did a great job incorporating the natural beauty of the site with a very playable golf course.

    — Jim · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  4. I own at Diamante in Cabo and their Dunes course is truly world class. Their El Cardonal course is no slouch either! I’ve also played Palmilla, which was very nice as well as Estrella Del Mar, which is a nice course near Mazatlan, but is in the middle of nowhere. Not sure how they stay in business. Quivera is next on my list. It looks stunning.

    — Jason · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  5. I live in Nashville. Norman’s Grove course south of town is a great and very natural course!

    — John · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  6. My only question given Mr. Frank’s assertion of Norman as an architect — is how many different layouts has the author played that are the handiwork of The Great White Shark? Getting some sort of context would help readers better understand where he’s coming from. Ditto where Nuevo Vallarta stands among those he’s played.

    I’ve played roughly 23 of his courses and some of have been exceptional — particularly liked his effort at Red Sky Ranch. Doonbeg was also good till the major changes there — really liked the par-3 14th although it’s now gone.

    — Harold Roberts · Friday December 2, 2016 ·

  7. I’ve probably played half a dozen of Norman's courses and seen at least that many more. I thought I said in the article that my views were based on a limited number in total but that what I’ve seen lately, particularly the new course at Nuevo Vallarta, make me interested to see more, which I hope to do soon.
    Jim Frank

    — Jim Frank · Friday December 2, 2016 ·



 


Note: You must preview comment before submitting. Thank you.





Loading
Waccamaw Golf Trail
Premier Properties Guide


Follow Links Magazine