Ranking the World – United Kingdom and Ireland

LINKS presents the start of a four-part series in which we’ll be ranking the nations of the world (outside of the U.S.) according to the quality of their golf. First up: the nations of the UK and Ireland.

By Darius Oliver

 

Ranking the World
Muirfield (Photo by Kevin Murray)

 

In the first of our four-part LINKS Magazine series, Scotland has emerged as the leading country in the United Kingdom & Ireland region. Though unlikely to shock many readers, the fact that Scotland finished a solitary point (out of 100) ahead of second-placed England may surprise.

In order to produce our rankings, we looked at the quantity and quality of golf courses in each country and considered the various elements that make a destination desirable to the traveling golfer. We didn’t just focus on the best and the most famous courses; we also factored in accessibility, history, and affordability. England was able to push Scotland because of the sheer volume of excellent golf across the country, and the fact that its Top 100-caliber courses are, on average, almost $50 cheaper to play than those in Scotland. So while Scotland pips England when it comes to a Bucket List, money-no-object-type tour of the very best courses in the country, in terms of putting together a Value itinerary of golf courses under $150 per round, England is a world beater.

The other great value destination in this part of the world is Wales, whose best courses are not only open and accessible to all, they are essentially half the price to play. Along with Scotland, Ireland, and Northern Ireland, Wales also has more golf courses per capita than the U.S., and only finished behind Ireland in fourth place because of the appeal of Ireland’s leading 5–15 courses. Despite lofty green fees, the likes of Ballybunion, Lahinch, Portmarnock, Adare Manor, Old Head, Tralee, and European Club remain enormously popular with visiting golfers. As do the Big Two in Northern Ireland—Royal Portrush and Royal County Down. The success of the 2019 Open Championship at Royal Portrush has shone a spotlight squarely on Northern Ireland as a golf destination, and it trailed the other four countries here only because the back-up options are not quite to the same standard as they are elsewhere. Plus, the competition in this region is awfully strong.

We hope readers will find these rankings interesting and perhaps useful when planning a golf trip abroad. Look for similar features later in the year, as we also rank the best golf nations of Europe, Asia/Oceania, and the Rest of the World.

 

HOW WE SCORED THEM:

NUMBER OF COURSES:

10 pts. = 5,000+, 9 = 2,000 to 5,000, 8 = 1,000 to 2,000, 7 = 500 to 1,000, 6 = 300 to 500, 5 = 100 to 300, 4 = 50 to 100, 3 = 25 to 50, 2 = 10 to 25, 1 = fewer than 10

POPULATION PER COURSE:

10 pts. = less than 10,000, 9 = less than 15,000 8 = less than 20,000, 7 = less than 25,000, 6 = less than 30,000, 5 = less than 50,000, 4 = less than 80,000, 3 = less than 100,000, 2 = more than 100,000

SCOTLAND – 552 Courses (7); Population 5.4 million. 9,782 people per course (10)

IRELAND – 350 Courses (6); Population 4.8 million. 13,714 people per course (9)

WALES – 189 Courses (5); Population 3.15 million. 16,666 people per course (8)

N. IRELAND – 94 Courses (4); Population 1.87 million. 19,893 people per course (8)

ENGLAND – 2,084 Courses (9); Population 55 million. 26,391 people per course (6)

Note: U.S. = 21,813 people per course

Ranking the World
Ballybunion Old (Photo by Evan Schiller)

BEST 5/15 COURSES

In order to properly consider the quality of a golf country, it’s important to look at both a small- and medium-sized sample of its best available golf courses. With the exception of the United States, Scotland’s Top 5 courses are unrivaled, but limiting the scope to just five would allow a small nation like Northern Ireland to compete with bigger countries because its best two courses are world-class and its next best, Portstewart and Ardglass, are also great charmers. Where the likes of England, Scotland, and Ireland separate themselves from Wales and Northern Ireland is when you consider more than just the leading handful of courses. It is here, with an expanded list of the Top 15 or more, that the strength of English golf becomes apparent. The 20th best course in England, for example, would probably rank third or fourth in Northern Ireland and Wales, and probably Top 10 in Ireland.

SCOTLAND – St. Andrews Old, Royal Dornoch, Muirfield, Turnberry, North Berwick, Kingsbarns, Carnoustie, Royal Aberdeen, Prestwick, Machrihanish, Trump Scotland, Royal Troon, Cruden Bay, Gleneagles, Castle Stuart, St. Andrews New, Brora, Gullane. Top 5 (10), Top 15 (10)

ENGLAND – Royal St. George’s, St. George’s Hill, Sunningdale Old/New, Swinley Forest, Royal Birkdale, West Sussex, Woking, Rye, Royal Lytham, Royal Liverpool, St. Enodoc, Woodhall Spa, Notts, The Berkshire, Silloth on Solway, Walton Heath, Wentworth, Ganton, Alwoodley, The Addington. Top 5 (9), Top 15 (10)

IRELAND – Ballybunion Old, Lahinch, Waterville, Carne, Trump Doonbeg, Adare Manor, Portmarnock, Old Head, Tralee, County Sligo, County Louth, European Club, Enniscrone, The Island, Ballyliffin, Dooks, K Club, Rosapenna. Top 5 (8), Top 15 (8)

WALES – Royal Porthcawl, Royal St. David’s, Tenby, Pennard, Nefyn & District, Celtic Manor, Aberdovey, Conwy, Southerndown, Ashburnham, Pyle & Kenfig. Top 5 (6), Top 15 (6)

N. IRELAND – Royal County Down, Royal Portrush Dunluce/Valley, Portstewart, Ardglass, Lough Erne, Castlerock, Malone. Top 5 (7), Top 15 (4)

AVERAGE GREEN FEES

Here we considered only courses that appear on the Top 100 lists for the UK & Ireland in both Golf World and Golf Monthly, the two leading golf publications in the UK. We awarded points as follows:

<$80: 10 points; <$100: 9 points; <$120: 8 points; <$150: 7 points; <$180: 6 points; <$220: 5 points; <$260: 4 points; <$300 3 points; >$300 2 points

WALES Avg. Top 100 = £75 U.S. $96 (9)

ENGLAND Avg. Top 100 = £140 U.S. $175 (6)

IRELAND Avg. Top 100 = €195 U.S. $215 (5)

SCOTLAND Avg. Top 100 = £185 U.S. $236 (4)

N. IRELAND Avg. Top 100 = £205 U.S. $262 (3)

Exchange Rates: 1£ = $1.28; 1€ = $1.11

Ranking the World
Royal St. George’s (photo by Kevin Murray)

BEST VALUE

A combination of Average Green Fees and Quality of the Top 15 Courses

ENGLAND – 8

WALES – 7

SCOTLAND – 7

IRELAND – 6

N. IRELAND – 4

BUCKET LIST TOUR

When money is no object…

SCOTLAND – St. Andrews Old, Royal Dornoch, Muirfield, Turnberry, North Berwick, Kingsbarns, Carnoustie, Royal Aberdeen, Prestwick, Machrihanish, Trump Scotland, Royal Troon, Cruden Bay, Gleneagles, Castle Stuart, Ardfin. (10)

ENGLAND – Royal St. George’s, St. George’s Hill, Sunningdale Old/New, Swinley Forest, Royal Birkdale, Royal Lytham, Royal Liverpool, West Sussex, Woking, Rye, St. Enodoc, Woodhall Spa, Notts, Walton Heath, Wentworth. (9)

IRELAND – Ballybunion Old, Lahinch, Waterville, Trump Doonbeg, Adare Manor, Portmarnock, Old Head, Tralee, European Club, K Club, County Sligo, County Louth, Enniscrone, Ballyliffin, Rosapenna. (8)

WALES – Royal Porthcawl, Royal St. David’s, Tenby, Pennard, Nefyn & District, Celtic Manor, Aberdovey, Southerndown, Ashburnham, Pyle & Kenfig. (6)

N. IRELAND – Royal County Down, Royal Portrush Dunluce/Valley, Portstewart, Ardglass, Lough Erne, Castlerock, Malone, Royal County Down, Annesley, Royal Belfast. (6)

VALUE TOUR

Good courses with peak green fees under U.S. $150

ENGLAND – Woodhall Spa, St. Enodoc, West Sussex, Ganton, Saunton East/West, Royal West Norfolk, Woking, Alwoodley, Worplesdon, West Hill, Notts, Silloth on Solway, Hunstanton, Moortown, The Addington, Royal Worlington & Newmarket. (10)

SCOTLAND – St. Andrews New, Machrihanish, Brora, Machrihanish Dunes, Murcar, The Machrie, Elie, Boat of Garten, Lundin, Panmure, Crail. (9)

IRELAND – Carne, Enniscrone, Dooks, Portsalon, Donegal, Rosapenna (two courses). (6)

WALES – Tenby, Pennard, Royal St. David’s, Nefyn & District, Aberdovey, Ashburnham, Southerndown. (6)

N. IRELAND – Ardglass, Royal Portrush (Valley), Castlerock. (3)

Ranking the World
Royal County Down (Photo by Evan Schiller)

 

While some readers plan their golf trips to a strict budget, others are only interested in hitting the premier tracks and ticking the famous courses off their Bucket List. For such readers, a 10-day tour of Scotland’s best courses is the golf trip of a lifetime and would include as a starting point St. Andrews (Old Course), Muirfield, Royal Dornoch, Trump Turnberry (Ailsa), Carnoustie, North Berwick, and Kingsbarns, as well as a selection from the likes of Royal Aberdeen, Prestwick, Royal Troon, Machrihanish, Castle Stuart, Ardfin, and Gleneagles. All great options.

Similarly, in England an open-checkbook 10-course trip would involve a mix of brilliant heathland courses and famous Open rota links. Scotland just shades England in this category, but England reverses the result when it comes to a Value Tour, where 10 courses under U.S. $150 are played. The choices in England are brilliantly varied and fun, from quirky links like St. Enodoc, Royal West Norfolk, Ganton, Saunton (East/ West), Hunstanton, and Silloth on Solway to an array of charming heathland tests around London and elsewhere. Incredibly, each of Woodhall Spa, West Sussex, Woking, Alwoodley, Worplesdon, West Hill, Notts, Moortown, and The Addington can be played for under $150 per round in peak season. As can Royal Worlington & Newmarket, which is arguably the best nine-hole golf course in the world and can be played all day for around $100, or for less than $40 in the afternoon.

Relatively speaking, the other country that performs better in the Value Trip category is Wales, primarily because with the exception of Royal Porthcawl each of its best 10 courses can be played in peak season for under $150. A similarly priced itinerary in Ireland would take in gems like Carne, Enniscrone, Dooks, Portsalon, and Rosapenna, but skip all of the country’s big guns.

ACCESS / TRAVEL

WALES – All Top 100 (UK & I) courses are accessible for visitors. (10)

N. IRELAND – All Top 100 (UK & I) courses are accessible, although tee times are limited at Royal Portrush in 2020 after the success of The Open. (10)

SCOTLAND – Access to Loch Lomond is difficult, but otherwise Top 100 (UK & I) courses are accessible. Tee times are limited at Muirfield, St. Andrews (Old Course), Ardfin, and Skibo Castle. (9)

ENGLAND – Access to Swinley Forest and Rye is difficult, but otherwise Top 100 (UK & I) courses are accessible. (9)

IRELAND – All Top 100 (UK & I) courses are accessible. Self-driving, however, is more difficult than in the UK because of narrow roads and Gaelic signage in some areas (i.e., North-West Coast). (9)

Ranking the World
Royal St. David’s (photo by Kevin Murray)

HISTORY / HYPE

SCOTLAND – The Home of Golf is always in fashion. (10)

ENGLAND – Lots of history and The Open is back (Sandwich) in 2020. Non-Open rota areas are perennially underrated in England. (9)

IRELAND – Green fees on the rise again suggest that Ireland is back as one of the world’s most desirable destinations. Playing the Irish Open at historic venues, plus a future Ryder Cup at Adare Manor, have helped the aura of Irish golf. (9)

N.IRELAND – Royal Portrush and Royal County Down are important courses globally, and the 2019 Open reinforced the magic of this small country as a golf destination. (8)

WALES – There is a great golf culture and golf history in Wales, but it remains very much off radar and underappreciated. (6)

 

What did you think of part one in our Ranking the World series? Let us know in the comments section below!